Sunday, 25 December 2016

Power ground cases of EMD locos and Action plan.

                   There have been large number of loco failures (eighteen) due to “Power ground Faults”. Three failures (20048, 20014 & 12280) due to power ground failure were in last two months alone.
                  Shed should measure IR value of Power circuit and Control circuit. Power circuit should further be sub-divided in branches and IR value of each branch should be taken. Any fall in value from previous reading or from other loco readings should be wakeup call and reason of drop in IR value should be carefully checked as per check list in each branch in all possible locations systematically. Shed should issue desirable IR value achieved in best 10% of loco) in power circuit and strive to maintain the same during every schedule.
 The detail of failures and action plan as per maintenance schedule is given in annexure. Most of these cases are due to insulation puncture of Traction motor power cables. Special drive should be launched for attending TM cables.
                  Suggested action plan to avoid such failures in near future is given below.
SN
ITEM
Details
Action to take
1
TM phase cable
1. Cable insulation damage inside and at facing point of  rubber cleat
(20011 on 8/7/07)
(20004 on7/11/07)
(20012 on3/5/08)
(20000 on 28/7/08)
(20015 on 7/11/08)
(2000 on 21/11/08)
(20017 on 18/2/08)
(20051 on 17/4/09)
(20014 on 1/2/08)
(12064 on 30/6/09)
(20079 on 11/8/09)
(12064 on 119/09)
(12166 on 23/10/09)
(12179 on 19/7/09)
1.a. Introduction of soft rubber gasket over       cable inside rubber cleat.
1.b. Proper securing of cables to arrest cable swing        during run.
2.Cable torn due to excessive lurching
(20048 on 23-6-2008)
2.a. Re-arrange cable route and keep    sufficient  cable length so that stretching of cable  does not take place at maximum lurching .
 Please ensure that the over length cable does not swing or rub.
2.b. Attention for Bogie and Yaw dampers   to avoid  lurching
3. Cable insulation rubbed with bolts of TM coupling bracket board.
(20014on 1/2/08)
3.a.  One special drive to inspect all such   vulnerable location.
3.b.  Application of suitable cable protection like heat shrinkable sleeve and gasket in such locations.
4. Un insulated portion of cable joint which is housed inside an umbrella boot over TM coupling bracket board burnt out. 
(12064 on 27/7/09)
4.a.  Inspection of umbrella boot for porosity       and other physical damage.
4.b. Replace the boot instead of repairing.
4.c. Cover up all un - insulated terminal  joints inside umbrella boot with self        fusible insulating tape.
4.d. Use sealant at the cable entrance into the umbrella boot to arrest water ingress inside umbrella boot.
2
TCC out put phase cable
1. TCC-2 phase V cable (out put) surface is cable insulator was worn out at the entrance of cable duct inside Central air compartment.
(20085 on 7/5/09)
1.a.  Checking of all power cable lay out         and fixtures during commissioning of   new locomotive.  It should be made 360 days schedule checking item.
1.b. One special drive for inspection of         power cables in all critical locations of         all locos.
3
TCC cable TM45RT cable
1. TCC2 cable TM45RT cable insulation cracked behind ECC1 cabinet and power ground occurred when came into contact with rain water.
(20014 on 28/6/10)
1.a.  Checking of all cable insulation behind        ECC1 cabinet by removing foot board    of all locos.
1.b.  Air blowing and proper cleaning of        cables of that location.
1.c. Apply sealant in leaky location .
1d. Door locking arrangement of all doors should be properly functional and water should not drip inside.
4
Insulator at the back of L456 reactor
 L456 reactor insulator in ECC2 back side of the reactor core damaged due to less gap with wall causing power ground.
(20048 on 6/5/2010)
1.a. One special drive for checking of gap        between the reactor and the ECC2 wall in all locos.
1.b Use insulated sheet or nomex paper in between reactor and ECC2 cabinet wall.
5
ECC2 terminal board
1.Rain water entered inside ECC2 and high voltage terminal board grounded.
(12280 on 30/6/2010)
1.a. Fabricate and introduce ECC2 cable duct cover for WDG4 locomotives to  restrict water ingress through harness.
1.b. Use RTV sealant at cable entrance for        ECC2. 
1.c. Check door gaskets for deformation and .If deformed replace it.
1.d. Ensure the ECC2 bottom drain hole   clean.
E) Transfer HV terminal points towards top of the terminal board.
F) Spray insulated paint over non insulated area of terminal board including terminal  lugs and posts

                    These instructions should be explained to concerned staffs and supervisors .Shed should create an exhaustive check list and action plan to attend power ground case.         

You are advised to introduce the above maintenance practice immediately and send feed back to HQ regularly.
Power ground cases of EMD locos and Action plan.
                   There have been large number of loco failures (eighteen) due to “Power ground Faults”. Three failures (20048, 20014 & 12280) due to power ground failure were in last two months alone.
                  Shed should measure IR value of Power circuit and Control circuit. Power circuit should further be sub-divided in branches and IR value of each branch should be taken. Any fall in value from previous reading or from other loco readings should be wakeup call and reason of drop in IR value should be carefully checked as per check list in each branch in all possible locations systematically. Shed should issue desirable IR value achieved in best 10% of loco) in power circuit and strive to maintain the same during every schedule.
 The detail of failures and action plan as per maintenance schedule is given in annexure. Most of these cases are due to insulation puncture of Traction motor power cables. Special drive should be launched for attending TM cables.
                  Suggested action plan to avoid such failures in near future is given below.
SN
ITEM
Details
Action to take
1
TM phase cable
1. Cable insulation damage inside and at facing point of  rubber cleat
(20011 on 8/7/07)
(20004 on7/11/07)
(20012 on3/5/08)
(20000 on 28/7/08)
(20015 on 7/11/08)
(2000 on 21/11/08)
(20017 on 18/2/08)
(20051 on 17/4/09)
(20014 on 1/2/08)
(12064 on 30/6/09)
(20079 on 11/8/09)
(12064 on 119/09)
(12166 on 23/10/09)
(12179 on 19/7/09)
1.a. Introduction of soft rubber gasket over       cable inside rubber cleat.
1.b. Proper securing of cables to arrest cable swing        during run.
2.Cable torn due to excessive lurching
(20048 on 23-6-2008)
2.a. Re-arrange cable route and keep    sufficient  cable length so that stretching of cable  does not take place at maximum lurching .
 Please ensure that the over length cable does not swing or rub.
2.b. Attention for Bogie and Yaw dampers   to avoid  lurching
3. Cable insulation rubbed with bolts of TM coupling bracket board.
(20014on 1/2/08)
3.a.  One special drive to inspect all such   vulnerable location.
3.b.  Application of suitable cable protection like heat shrinkable sleeve and gasket in such locations.
4. Un insulated portion of cable joint which is housed inside an umbrella boot over TM coupling bracket board burnt out. 
(12064 on 27/7/09)
4.a.  Inspection of umbrella boot for porosity       and other physical damage.
4.b. Replace the boot instead of repairing.
4.c. Cover up all un - insulated terminal  joints inside umbrella boot with self        fusible insulating tape.
4.d. Use sealant at the cable entrance into the umbrella boot to arrest water ingress inside umbrella boot.
2
TCC out put phase cable
1. TCC-2 phase V cable (out put) surface is cable insulator was worn out at the entrance of cable duct inside Central air compartment.
(20085 on 7/5/09)
1.a.  Checking of all power cable lay out         and fixtures during commissioning of   new locomotive.  It should be made 360 days schedule checking item.
1.b. One special drive for inspection of         power cables in all critical locations of         all locos.
3
TCC cable TM45RT cable
1. TCC2 cable TM45RT cable insulation cracked behind ECC1 cabinet and power ground occurred when came into contact with rain water.
(20014 on 28/6/10)
1.a.  Checking of all cable insulation behind        ECC1 cabinet by removing foot board    of all locos.
1.b.  Air blowing and proper cleaning of        cables of that location.
1.c. Apply sealant in leaky location .
1d. Door locking arrangement of all doors should be properly functional and water should not drip inside.
4
Insulator at the back of L456 reactor
 L456 reactor insulator in ECC2 back side of the reactor core damaged due to less gap with wall causing power ground.
(20048 on 6/5/2010)
1.a. One special drive for checking of gap        between the reactor and the ECC2 wall in all locos.
1.b Use insulated sheet or nomex paper in between reactor and ECC2 cabinet wall.
5
ECC2 terminal board
1.Rain water entered inside ECC2 and high voltage terminal board grounded.
(12280 on 30/6/2010)
1.a. Fabricate and introduce ECC2 cable duct cover for WDG4 locomotives to  restrict water ingress through harness.
1.b. Use RTV sealant at cable entrance for        ECC2. 
1.c. Check door gaskets for deformation and .If deformed replace it.
1.d. Ensure the ECC2 bottom drain hole   clean.
E) Transfer HV terminal points towards top of the terminal board.
F) Spray insulated paint over non insulated area of terminal board including terminal  lugs and posts

                    These instructions should be explained to concerned staffs and supervisors .Shed should create an exhaustive check list and action plan to attend power ground case.         

You are advised to introduce the above maintenance practice immediately and send feed back to HQ regularly.
                      Maintenance of rectifier.


Recently loco no.16446  failed on 16/07/2014 due to failure of rectifier (a diode had burnt).
In addition to maintenance instructions and testing procedures of rectifiers issued earlier vide Diesel/ Maint. /HQs & Shed/30, dated: 05-09-2011, Sheds are directed to implement following measures immediately for improving reliability.
1.   Cleaning:
In situ air blowing and gentle wiping of diode should be done in every schedule. Inaccessible area should be cleaned by long stemmed bottle brush in every schedule. Spray cleaning of diodes should be done in M4 and above schedule by opening cover. After spray cleaning, diode should be wiped dry.
2.   Condition monitoring in trip schedule:
a)    Voltage spikes: Diodes are venerable to voltage spikes and spikes if not arrested will cause long term damage to diodes. Snubber capacitors and resistors should be visually checked for deformation due to short circuit, overheating and loose terminals. Capacitance measurement of the capacitors should be measured by capacitance meter. Capacitance value should remain within ± 10% of original value. A healthy capacitor shall give a kick and show very high resistance. A capacitor showing short circuit or low resistance (less than 10 K ohm) should be rejected.
b)    Temperature: Surface temperature of individual diode should be measured and its trend monitoring should be done. Temperature rise beyond 10% of last value is a cause of concern and warrants detailed investigation in section.
c)    Resistance: Forward and Reverse resistance of diode should be measured by 1000V meggar. Forward resistance should be zero and reverse resistance should be in Mega Ohms ( 200-500 MΩ).If any diode is showing less reverse resistance , it should be changed. Care should be taken before conducting Meggaring by isolating circuit wire no 34 and 36 from rectifier out going terminal board to avoid damage to electronic components.
3.      Heat sink: Heat sink should not be opened by shed. It has been learnt that diodes are removed from heat sink during stripping. This practice should be immediately stopped as diodes and heat sinks are factory fitted by applying suitable heat conducting agent.
4.     Creepage path:  Creepage path for current flow should not be permitted. It should be arrested by ensuring regular cleaning and providing additional insulation layer in vulnerable locations.


Sheds are advised to implement the above instructions and to send feed back to HQ.
Traction alternator rectifier maintenance and test procedure.
          Eleven cases of rectifier failure have been observed in in last eighteen months. Details are given below:
Loco No
Date of fail
Shed
Reason of failure
16007
3.3.2010
N
Thermal switch damaged due to flash over in rectifier panel
16281
24.8.2011
M
Rectifier cable damaged
16518
10.7.2011
M
Rectifier +ve bus bar insulator punctured
20074
31.3.2010
S
One fuse blown
12178
8.4.2010
S
Two nos. fuse blown and two nos. diodes short circuited.
12185
30-05-2010
S
Two nos. diodes short circuited.
20070
03-09-2010
S
One diode open circuited
20073
01-03-2011
S
Five fuse blown and three diodes short circuited
20070
10-08-2011
S
Six diodes open circuited and five nos. Fuse blown
12176
18-08-2011
S
Rectifier panel fuse blown.
Field visit and interaction with maintenance supervisors revealed gross lack of knowledge on maintenance and testing of rectifiers. All sheds are directed to implement the instructions issued below during maintenance of rectifiers.
1.   Cleaning:
Dirt causes poor heat dissipation of diodes and with increasing heat   diodes behaviour changes. Dirt and water vapour provides creepage path causing damage of rectifier.
Check rectifier panels for dust and dirt. If dirt presence is more check cyclonic filter condition and rectifier panel sealing and TA compartment partition wall sealing and take necessary corrective action.
1.1  Running schedule cleaning–
Remove the rectifier cover and blow clean compressed air at approximate 2 kg/cm² to remove dust, dirt and soot deposition. In case soot/oil deposit is found on glass epoxy items, heat sink and bus bars, it may be cleaned with the help of cloth soaked in cleaning solvent. Use long bottle brush cleaner for better accessibility.
1.2 Heavy  schedule cleaning For ALCO locomotives :
The complete rectifier panel shall be unloaded in yearly and above schedule. Clean each part properly with help of cloth soaked in recommended solvent. (Dober Chemical Corporation Cleaner 6006, or Turco Chemical Company Steamfas).
For EMD locomotives :
The complete rectifier panel shall be unloaded in yearly and above schedule. Clean each part properly with help of cloth soaked in recommended solvent. (Dober Chemical Corporation Cleaner 6006, or Turco Chemical Company Steamfas).
1.3 CAUTION-
The contact surfaces of the diodes and heat sink assemblies must not be cleaned with an abrasive material or wire brush. Such cleaning will destroy the finish and reduce heat rejection capability.
Water or cleaning solution allowed to contaminate the arc quenching sand inside the fuse body can cause the fuse to explode when it is required to isolate a shorted diode.
2.   Inspection for Blown FUSE –
For ALCO locos- Check fuses for any signs of cracks or burning. Flag of the micro switches on all the fuses should be in closed condition. Check functioning of micro switch and LED by manual operation.
For EMD Loco:- check fuses for any signs of cracks or burning. Check fuse indicating pin. If it protrudes 5mm from the normal position remove the fuse and check fuse continuity.  If the fuse is found open, check corresponding diodes of the phase.
3.   Inspection of Snubber circuit
3.1                Snubber resistors-
Visually check Snubber resistor for open circuit, overheating and loose terminals. Check resistance if any abnormality is noticed. Snubber resistors used in alternator-mounted rectifiers are of rating 20 ohm, 250 watts (for BHEL rectifiers) and 22 ohm, 50 watts (for HIND rectifiers). Replace the resistor if it's value is out of the above range or if there is physical damage. Snubber circuit has been removed in EMD make TA ,but it is still in service in CGL and DMW make TA 17 in EMD locos. Check resistance and capacitance value during running schedule.
3.2                Snubber capacitors-
Visually check Snubber capacitors for deformation due to short circuit, overheating and loose terminals. Check capacitance if any abnormality  is noticed. Snubber capacitors used in the alternator-mounted rectifiers are of rating 1.5 MFD 3000V (for BHEL rectifiers) and 0.47 MFD, 2000V (for Hind Rectifiers). The capacitors should be checked using an analogue multi meter. A healthy capacitor shall give a kick and show very high resistance. A capacitor showing short circuit or low resistance (less than 10 K ohm) should be rejected. The capacitance value should be measured using a portable capacitance meter. The capacitance value should be within +10% range. Record of measurement should be kept. Any capacitor showing a reduction in capacitance by 10% over the last measurement should be rejected.
4.   Diode inspection-
If any fuse in the rectifier panel is found open check corresponding diodes of the phase. To check the diode following test can be followed-
4.1                Diode resistance check -
Check forward resistance and reverse resistance of diode.
For Alco locos if reverse resistance is high (> 100 kΩ) and forward resistance is low (About 850 Ω) than diode is perfect but if the reverse resistance is low along with the forward resistance than diode should be tested for Reverse Voltage Test.
For EMD locos check the above and if reverse resistance is high (> 30 kΩ) and forward resistance is low (About 10-20 Ω) than diode is perfect but if the reverse resistance is low along with the forward resistance than diode should be tested for Reverse Voltage Test. The 30K-ohm value is for an individual diode isolated from the circuit. A diode not isolated from the circuit should register greater than 2K Ohms for EMD locos.
4.2                Reverse Voltage Test – It should be conducted by connecting diode in reverse direction and increasing voltage from 0 to 1000 V. Measure correspondingly reverse leakage current (Ir).
If the Ir is less than 30 mA accept the diode and if the Ir value is more than 30 mA, reject the diode.
It is better idea to have paired diodes i.e. diodes having same leakage current in one panel.
4.3                DC Megger Test- Use a hand-cranked or battery operated Megger to test the diode. Connect one lead to diode pigtail and other lead to base of diode. If using a hand crank meter, it is important to crank slowly at first, then gradually increase the cranking speed to medium. Depending on polarity, the reading should be zero (blocking) when connected one way, then by reversing test leads, there should be a definite megger reading of at least one Megohm or better.
4.4                DC Voltage Test-
Connect a 110-volt incandescent lamp in series with the suspected diode, and apply 64 vdc (from the locomotive batteries) to this series connected circuit, then, reverse diode leads and observe the lamp response.
If the diode is good, a light turns ON when the diode is connected one way, and turns OFF when connected the other way.
If the lamp turns ON both ways, the diode is shorted out.
If the lamp remains OFF when the diode is connected both ways, the diode is open circuit.
4.5                AC Voltage Test-
Connect a 60 to 100-watt, 110-volt incandescent lamp in series with the suspect diode. Apply 110-115 volts, 60-hertz shop power to the circuit, then reverse diode leads and observe the lamp response.
If the diode is good, the lamp turns ON at about half of its normal light level (half wave rectification), when the diode is connected in one   direction, and is OFF when connected the other way
If the lamp is close to full light level, the diode is shorted.
If the lamp does not light, the diode is open.
5.   Assembly-
Replace defective diodes with good diodes of identical polarity, and voltage class (or higher voltage class).
For EMD locos apply a thin coating of compound 8346481 to the base of the diode hex to cover the surface. Do not apply on threads. With special diode socket and 0 – 50 ft.-lbs. Torque wrench, torque diodes to 45 to 47 Nm (33 to 35 ft.-lbs.). Torque diode terminal lug bolts to between 15 to 18 Nm (11 to 13 ft.-lbs). Tightness as recommended by OEM should be ensured by using torque wrench.
For ALCO locos apply thin layer of heat sink compound such as Dow corning make DC340R or equivalent, smear it out with clean cotton then place diode on heat sink. Place the clamp, insert Allen screws (M8) then tighten it by torque wrench diagonally setting torque at 12.5 NM.
6.   Replacement-
All diodes should be replaced after 10 years of service due to thermal/mechanical degradation.